Harris, Jayapal Introduce Bicameral Bill to Place Moratorium on Immigration Detention Facilities
WASHINGTON, D.C. – U.S. Senator Kamala D. Harris (D-CA) and Representative Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) today introduced the Detention Oversight Not Expansion (DONE) Act, which would increase oversight of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention centers, and halt funds for construction or expansion of new facilities. Over the last two decades, the federal immigration system has undergone a dramatic expansion that has led to a 400% increase in detained non-citizens with an increasing number being children, women and pregnant women. These detainees are often mistreated by ICE agents and forced to reside in deplorable conditions with their rights being habitually and systemically violated.
“ICE’s indiscriminate approach to immigration enforcement continues to sow fear and anxiety in communities across the nation and strict oversight is long overdue,” said Senator Harris. “It is unconscionable to subject detainees to inhumane conditions that include cases of unchecked sexual abuse, outright medical negligence, lack of access to counsel, and in some cases, even death. It’s time to end the expansion of these facilities that divert these resources to address true public safety threats.”
“Even though the U.S. already houses the largest immigrant detention system in the world, the Trump Administration wants more detention beds without any oversight,” said Representative Jayapal. “The countless number of horrific assaults, senseless abuses and needless deaths of immigrants in detention prove that ICE isn’t able to police itself. Our bill demands a higher accountability of ICE and a stop to detention expansion because our nation doesn’t need more violence and further militarization – what we need is comprehensive and humane reform and real accountability.”
"Through our network of visitation programs and our hotline, we’ve documented countless stories of detained individuals who’ve been abused by ICE and private prison companies. The abuses range from sexual assault to forced labor to medical neglect and even death. These inhumane conditions have become the status quo in the U.S. immigration detention system and we refuse to tolerate it,” said Christina Fialho, a California attorney and co-founder/executive director of Freedom for Immigrants (formerly CIVIC). "Sen. Kamala Harris and Rep. Pramila Jayapal’s bicameral bill, the Detention Oversight Not Expansion (DONE) Act, builds upon the Dignity Not Detention Act, our groundbreaking legislation passed in California last year. But states alone cannot change this massive system. It’s time for the federal government to step in and demand transparency and accountability. It’s time for us to be done with immigration detention."
“Time and time again, ICE has proven itself incapable of comporting with basic civil and human rights—especially when it comes to overseeing its massive immigration detention infrastructure,” said Madhuri Grewal, Federal Immigration Policy Counsel for the ACLU. “Through our litigation, advocacy, and reporting, the ACLU has consistently found ICE to flaunt its own minimal detention standards and continually detain immigrants who are pregnant and asylum seekers, have mental disabilities, and other vulnerable populations—often in facilities operated by private prison companies. Even worse, ICE is charged with self-monitoring—a process that has allowed the agency to ignore or dismiss egregious violations and contributed to multiple deaths in detention. These horrific conditions, in combination with the massive rise in ICE detention since the late 1990s, have led to an agency that needs serious systematic change. This bill from Senator Harris and Representative Jayapal—which imposes a moratorium on further expansion, moves to cut the number of detention beds used by ICE, and includes critical oversight and accountability measures for violations—is an important step forward.”
Reports by the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) have consistently determined the rights of detainees in these facilities are undermined, and that ICE has failed to provide a safe and healthy environment for them.
Some of the unjust consequences include:
- Sexual Abuse. Between FY12 and March 2018, ICE received 1,448 allegations of sexual abuse in detention facilities. Only a small percent of these claims have been investigated.
- Medical Negligence. While in ICE custody, detainees regularly receive substandard care. Pregnant women in particular receive insufficient medical attention while in custody, resulting in dehydration and even miscarriages. In FY17 alone, at least three women reportedly miscarried while in ICE custody.
- Access to Counsel. Detainees often struggle to secure representation due to language barriers, wait times in detention facilities, and distance between detention facilities and government provided aid, all of which raise serious due process concerns.
- Deaths. There have been over 170 reported deaths in ICE custody since 2003.
Despite the persistent mismanagement of detention facilities that have resulted in human rights abuses, the Trump Administration is seeking to increase funding for ICE’s civil immigration detention system by $2.7 billion in next year’s budget without making much-needed reforms to the current system.
The DONE Act would:
- Require the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security to submit a report to Congress that includes a plan to 1.) decrease the number of detention beds by 50% of the number available as of the date of the enactment of this Act by using alternatives to detention that are less costly to the taxpayer and have been shown to be successful and 2.) restore and expand the Family Case Management Program.
- Require the DHS Office of Inspector General to conduct unannounced inspections of all immigration detention facilities to ensure compliance with national standards, focusing on the health, safety, and care of detainees, especially as it relates to pregnant women. DHS OIG shall submit a report of its findings to Congress.
- Require the DHS Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties conduct investigations, and submit a report of its findings to Congress.
- Mandates that facility contracts will be terminated for facilities receiving less than adequate ratings in the two most recent inspections, audits, or investigations conducted by DHS OIG.
The DONE Act is supported by National Immigration Justice Center, Moms Rising, UnidosUS (formerly National Council of La Raza), Women’s Refugee Commission, Human Rights Watch, American Civil Liberties Union, Friends Committee on National Legislation, Asian Pacific Institute on Gender-Based Violence, Immigration Hub, Church World Service, Asian Americans Advancing Justice, Network Lobby for Social Change, Coalition for Human Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles, National Latina Institute for Reproductive Health, Northwest Immigrant Rights Project, OneAmerica, Illinois Coalition for Immigrant Refugee Rights, and Freedom for Immigrants (formerly CIVIC).
Senator Harris has long been outspoken about the need for oversight and reform of detention facilities. Last May, Harris questioned former DHS Secretary John Kelly on DHS’s likely expanded use of privately operated immigration detention facilities. In December, she led a group of colleagues in urging House and Senate Appropriators to mandate that all facilities within ICE’s detention system meet national standards as a condition for funding. Harris also urged Senate Appropriators to decrease funding for Trump’s deportation force including detention beds as part of both the FY18 and FY19 budgets.
The text of the bill is available here.
A one pager for the bill is available here.
Next Article Previous Article